Analysis of EID and ID Usage

Under development

So far, this just provides a background on where the calls are occurring in the code. The section immediately below is the beginnings of
a higher level analysis of what tools show which kinds of ids.

Presentation-Layer Visibility of DisplayIds and Eids

View	Eids	DisplayIds	Explanation
Grade Book			Need to check this one
Portal Bug Report			Looks like it shows the eid on screen to that user and then mails it to us.
Roster			Each student's eid is visible alongside his/her name for the instructor AND THE OTHER STUDENTS to see
RWiki			Each page shows who last modified it, format: First Last (DisplayID)
Samigo			Student eids are displayed on the Scores and Questions pages alongside the student's full name (visible to instructor)
Site Info			As far as I can tell the only ids shown here are DisplayIds, including Student DisplayIds
SU Tool			The user logs in with his/her own Eid
WebDav			The user connects via his/her own Eid and it's that Eid that's displayed under the "Upload/Download Multiple Resources"
Chat	Eids??	DisplayIds??	Displays first name lastname
Message Center	Eids??	DisplayIds??	Displays kerberos id in 2.1.x
Gradebook	Eids??	DisplayIds??	Displays kerberos id in 2.1.x in column labeled Student ID

A summary of the usage of EIDs in Sakai 2.3 Tools

Calls to UserDirectoryProvider.getUser() by Class

Class	Method
edu.amc.sakai.user.JLDAPDirectoryProvider	getUsers(Collection)
es.udl.asic.user.OpenLdapDirectoryProvider	getUsers(Collection)
org.sakaiproject.component.umsert.user.IMSEntUserDirectoryProvider	getUsers(Collection)
org.sakaiproject.component.kerberos.user.KerberosUserDirectoryProvider	findUserByEmail(UserEdit, String)
org.sakaiproject.component.kerberos.user.KerberosUserDirectoryProvider	getUsers(Collection)
org.sakaiproject.provider.ucd.impl.UserDirectoryProviderImpl	findUserByEmail(UserEdit, String)
org.sakaiproject.provider.ucd.impl.UserDirectoryProviderImpl	getUsers(Collection)
org.sakaiproject.provider.user.FilterUserDirectoryProvider	getUser(UserEdit)
org.sakaiproject.provider.user.SampleUserDirectoryProvider	findUserByEmail(UserEdit, String)
org.sakaiproject.provider.user.SampleUserDirectoryProvider	findUsersByEmail(String, UserFactory)
org.sakaiproject.provider.user.SampleUserDirectoryProvider	getUsers(Collection)
org.sakaiproject.user.impl.BaseUserDirectoryService	getUser(String)
org.sakaiproject.user.impl.BaseUserDirectoryService	getUserId(String)

Calls to UserDirectoryService.getUserId by Class

Class	Method
org.sakaiproject.user.impl.BaseUserDirectoryService	findUsersByEmail(String)
org.sakaiproject.user.impl.BaseUserDirectoryService	getUsersByEid(String)

Calls to User.getEid() by Class – ignoring the Classes listed above

Class	Method	Tool
org.sakaiproject.component.app.profile.ProfileManagerImpl	getEnterpriseIdByAgentUuid(String)	Profile
org.sakaiproject.component.app.roster.RosterManagerImpl	createParticipantByUser(User)	Roster
org.sakaiproject.content.tool.ResourcesAction	buildWebdavContext(VelocityPortlet, Context, RunData, SessionState)	WebDav
org.sakaiproject.metaobj.security.impl.sakai.SecurityBase	morphAgent(User)	N/A
org.sakaiproject.site.tool.SiteAction	doAdd_participant(RunData)	SiteTool
org.sakaiproject.site.tool.SiteAction	sendSiteRequest(SessionState, String, int, List)	SiteTool
org.sakaiproject.tool.assessment.integration.helper.integrated.AgentHelperImpl	getEid(String)	Samigo Services
org.sakaiproject.tool.assessment.integration.helper.integrated.AgentHelperImpl	getEidById(String)	Samigo Services
org.sakaiproject.tool.su.SuTool	su()	SU Tool
org.sakaiproject.user.tool.UsersAction	doSave(RunData, Content)	User Tool
org.sakaiproject.util.ErrorReporter	logAndMail(String...)	Portal Bug Report

Calls to User.getDisplayId() by Class

Class	Method	Tool
org.sakaiproject.assignment.impl.BaseAssignmentService	getGradesSpreadsheet(String)	Assignments
org.sakaiproject.authz.impl.BaseMember	getUserDisplayId()	N/A
org.sakaiproject.component.section.facade.impl.sakai21.SakaiUtil	convertUser(User)	N/A
org.sakaiproject.event.impl.UsageSessionServiceAdapter.BaseUsageSession	getUserDisplayId()	N/A
org.sakaiproject.site.impl.BaseSiteService	getEntityDescription(Reference)	N/A
org.sakaiproject.site.tool.SiteAction.Participant	getDisplayId()	SiteTool
uk.ac.cam.caret.sakai.rwiki.utils.UserDisplayHelper	formatDisplayName(String, String)	RWiki

Potential exposed presentation of Eids

Tool	Explanation
Profile
Roster
WebDav
SiteTool
Samigo
SU Tool
Portal BugReport

Exposed presentation of DisplayIds

Tool	Explanation
Assignments
SiteTool
RWiki	Each page shows who last modified it, format: First Last (DisplayID)

Some explanation of how userId is supplied for a provided user (in answer to Jon's question)

"org.sakaiproject.user.impl.BaseUserDirectoryService"


public String getUserId(String eid) throws UserNotDefinedException
	{
		eid = cleanEid(eid);

		// first, check our map
		String id = m_storage.checkMapForId(eid);
		if (id != null) return id;

		// if we don't have an id yet for this eid, and there's a provider that recognizes this eid, allocate an id
		if (m_provider != null)
		{
			// allocate the id to use if this succeeds
			id = assureUuid(null, eid);

			// make a new edit to hold the provider's info, hoping it will be filled in
			BaseUserEdit user = new BaseUserEdit((String) null);
			user.m_id = id;
			user.m_eid = eid;

			// check with the provider
			if (m_provider.getUser(user))
			{
				// record the id -> eid mapping (could possibly fail if somehow this eid was mapped since our test above)
				m_storage.putMap(user.getId(), user.getEid());

				return user.getId();
			}
		}

		// not found
		throw new UserNotDefinedException(eid);
	}

Version	Author	Date
1.0	James Renfro	12/01/2006
1.1	James Renfro	12/20/2006